Printful vs Printify for Etsy sellers

Printful vs Printify vs Gelato for Etsy — integration, shipping speed, catalog size, and which POD partner fits your niche.

Quick comparison

FAQ

Can I connect Printful or Printify directly to Etsy?

Yes. Both integrate with Etsy so orders can sync and fulfill automatically once you link your shop and publish products. Always test one order yourself before running ads.

Is Printify cheaper than Printful for Etsy sellers?

Printify's base product costs are often lower because you choose from many print providers. Printful tends to cost more per item but offers consistent quality and branding options. Compare the exact SKU you plan to sell, not average prices.

Should I use one POD supplier or several?

Start with one partner until fulfillment is reliable, then add a second only if you need a product category your first choice doesn't carry well (e.g. wall art vs apparel).

Is Printful good for Etsy?

Yes — Printful integrates directly with Etsy, handles production and shipping, and is known for consistent quality. Compare your exact product SKU against Printify before you commit; Printify is often cheaper per item but uses multiple print partners.

Etsy Printful — how do I connect them?

In Printful, add your Etsy shop under Stores, approve permissions, then publish products from Printful to Etsy. Test one order yourself before running ads. See our full Printful vs Printify comparison for catalog and shipping tradeoffs.

Printful Etsy vs Printify Etsy — which is cheaper?

Printify is often lower per SKU because you pick a print provider; Printful is usually higher per item with more consistent branding and quality. Compare the exact product you plan to sell, not blog averages.

Full guide (canonical): https://makertoolstack.com/guides/print-on-demand-comparison

More comparisons: https://makertoolstack.com/guides/best-listing-tools

Affiliate disclosure: https://makertoolstack.com/disclosure